Showing posts with label ACA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACA. Show all posts

Monday, October 29, 2012

CHI 2012 Keynote Spotlight: Dr. Mark Smith, President and CEO, California HealthCare Foundation

Dr. Mark Smith
Dr. Mark Smith, a board-certified internist who has served as president and CEO of the California HealthCare Foundation since its formation in 1996, will keynote CHI 2012, the annual meeting of biomedical executives, entreprenuers, investors and policymakers. The event, happening Nov. 8 at Gilead Sciences in Foster City, Calif., brings together policymakers with representatives of CHI’s member organizations to discuss critical issues and opportunities facing the biomedical community. Click here to register by Friday, Nov. 2.

CHCF is an independent philanthropy headquartered in Oakland, Calif. dedicated to improving the health of Californians with special concern for the underserved.

Q: In a blog post for JAMA Forum earlier this year, you argue that, regardless of the Supreme Court decision or the results of the upcoming presidential election, health reform is already happening, and will continue. Explain to our audience, briefly, what you mean by this?

A: While the outcome of the presidential and congressional elections matters a great deal in some areas of healthcare policy, there are number of big trends in the delivery system that are a result of forces that are independent of these elections. In particular, cost pressures on every sector of healthcare will only intensify, no matter what the outcome of the election. Consolidation (of hospitals with each other, hospitals with physicians, and physician groups with each other) will continue. Novel arrangements between payers and provider systems aimed at reducing spend will persist; and consumers, spurred, in part, by growing out-of-pocket responsibilities, will become more and more price sensitive and more demanding of convenient customer service attributes which they have come to expect from other aspects of their lives.

Q: The ACA gave rise to a lot of talk about cost containment. How big of a role do you suppose personalized medicine will play in driving down costs?

A: Too soon to tell. I can certainly imagine circumstances in which the ability to accurately predict an individual patient's response to an expensive medicine, say chemotherapy or biologic anti-inflammatory, may reduce expenditures on ineffective medicine, despite the expense of the initial test. But I can also see circumstances in which breathtakingly expensive personalized approaches provide only marginal increases of effectiveness with dramatic increases in costs. The good news (from the perspective of cost control) is that I think the approval and reimbursement environment of the future will be more on evidence and less on marketing.

Q: We stand at a time when policy often lags the pace of scientific advance. Genetic sequencing and biomarkers are examples. How do we keep the two in unison?

A: We can't. No matter how much we'd like to do so, the policy environment will never be as dynamic, nimble, or unpredictable as the breakthroughs in biomedical science. So, the question is not so much how we keep them in unison as how we can keep the policy environment from getting decades behind the science, as it is in many areas now. It will require new approaches to conditional approval, post-approval surveillance, collaborative funding of trials, etc. The most hopeful development is the progress of digitized medical records, computing power, and rapid learning systems which can compress the time needed for thoughtful collection, review and analysis of clinical data and, in some instances, replace traditional clinical trials.

Q: If you could change a single healthcare policy, at the state or federal level, what would it be and why?

A: Begin to develop a single national policy with regard to scope of practice, so that improvements and advances in the productivity and capacities of healthcare workers and patients themselves would not have to be battled out board by board, state by state.

Q: What are you most looking forward to in anticipation of CHI 2012?

A: The election will be over, some uncertainty will be reduced, and we can look forward to how to work together to strengthen the healthcare system while making it more affordable.

CHI-Advancing California biomedical research and innovation




Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Speaker Spotlight: Tom Campbell, Ph.D., Dean of Chapman University School of Law

Tom Campbell
Campbell, Ph.D., a former U.S. congressman and state senator who serves as dean of the Chapman University School of Law, will give the keynote address for CHI 2012, the annual meeting of CHI. CHI 2012 focuses on the relationship between biomedical innovation and public policy. The goal of the meeting is to focus on the biomedical community’s work and needs, and how the industry can sustain California’s leadership in medical innovation.

Campbell served five terms in Congress, was also a California senator, and the director of finance for the state of California. He also served as the dean at the Haas School of Business at UC Berkeley and a Stanford University professor for almost two decades before that. He will provide CHI 2012 attendees with economic predictions based on the election, share insights on the future of healthcare legislation and address what is wrong with the political process. Campbell graduated with a doctorate degree in economics from the University of Chicago. He received his law degree from Harvard Law School.


Q: In your opinion, how likely are we to see the Affordable Care Act repealed?

A: The outcome of the presidential, Senate, and House elections will determine the future of our nation’s healthcare system. Bearing in mind that the president’s healthcare act passed under reconciliation, by which a Senate filibuster was avoided, it is also true that it can be repealed by a simple majority without the possibility of a filibuster. Thus, it is safe to assume that if the Republicans gain the presidency and have 50 senators, and hold the House majority, the president’s healthcare statute will be repealed. What will replace it is not certain, of course; but it is unlikely that the individual mandate will survive.

Q: What features of the ACA do you anticipate will survive if Obama is not re-elected?

A: Gov. Romney has recently announced he’ll keep the obligation for carriers to take all insurance applicants, even those with pre-existing conditions. Obviously, that will necessitate higher premiums in all insurance contracts than before the law was enacted, but no higher than what they are at present. As there will no longer be a minimum set of coverages that have to be present in all contracts, we can expect a wider choice of such options, offered by private insurers. Some, for instance, will not include contraceptive care.

Q: Do you anticipate Medicare will be turned to a voucher system?

A: A capitated federal grant to the states for Medicaid, and to seniors directly for Medicare, is likely, with increased numbers of eligibles, but reduced compensated services. If the president is re-elected, then we might still see some changes, as individual states take advantage of that part of the National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius decision that allows states to exempt themselves from federal compulsion.

Q: How are states currently dealing with this anticipated change?

A: The governor of Maine is attempting the argument that his state should be allowed to cover fewer people under Medicaid, with, admittedly, less money than coming from the federal government, rather than being compelled to cover with Maine’s own matching money the broader categories required by the federal government. Also, the president announced several months ago that he was going to propose a compromise with religious institutions; the details of that compromise will have to be worked out if he is re-elected.

Q: What will you draw on to give your keynote speech to CHI’s audience of legislators, biomedical entrepreneurs and executives, investors and academic researchers?

A: I will draw on my own experience in public life, having served as a member of Congress in what seemed a permanent Republican minority (1988-1992), then as part of the first Republican majority in 40 years (1995-2000), and in a legislative body with a very different set of procedures, the California Senate, just as term limits were being applied (1993-1995). I’ll have some iconoclastic recommendations regarding term limits, super-majority requirements for votes, and selection of committee chairs. I’ll touch on the effect of money in politics over the time the U.S. Supreme Court has redefined the relevant rules, my efforts as part of the bipartisan team to adopt McCain-Feingold (since struck down by the Supreme Court), and the rise of both self-funded candidates and super PACs.


It is not too late to register for CHI 2012, taking place Nov. 8 at Gilead Sciences Campus in Foster City, Calif. Click here to view the full agenda and speaker line-up for CHI 2012.


CHI-Advancing California biomedical research and innovation


Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Speaker Spotlight: Dana Goldman, Ph.D., Director of the USC Leonard D. Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics, UCLA Adjunct Professor

Goldman is a nationally-recognized health economist influential in both academic and policy circles. He is the author of more than 100 articles and book chapters, including articles in some of the most prestigious medical, economic, health policy, and statistics journals. He is a health policy advisor to the Congressional Budget Office, and is a frequent speaker on healthcare issues. He joins us July 12 at UCLA for “California: Uniting Science and Policy to Advance Cancer Care.” It’s not too late to register for the event – contact Marisa Reinoso at reinoso@chi.org.

Q: What policies have greatly impacted cancer care in your opinion?


A: I think what people don’t realize is just how important reimbursement and other health policies are in terms of changing the way treatment gets delivered. For example, if you look at the rules for Medicare reimbursement, most of the reimbursement has been generous, historically, for infused therapies. And the result is that we have many infused therapies for cancer. And the question is whether that generous reimbursement is going to continue. Even more important is the relationship between reimbursement and future innovation.

The idea is that we have the luxury in the United States because we have reimbursed, historically, at generous levels that, for our conditions, we’ve actually made progress. We’re actually winning the war on cancer and we’re doing it through treatment, as well as diagnosis. The issue is whether that type of progress will continue.

Q: You talk a lot about the importance, both from a health standpoint and an economic one, of prevention and preventive care. How much of this will rely on medical diagnostics and advanced technologies and how much is it reliant on an individual to change his or her behavior?

A: What we found is the change in behavior is notoriously difficult. If you roll the clock back 50 years and you think about hypertension, it has always been a serious health dilemma in this country. But we know there are behavioral modifications that will help people – they can change their diet, reduce their salt intake and exercise more. But what we found is that very few people comply.

Actually, the introduction of drugs, mainly beta blockers, diuretics, calcium channel blockers, and a whole host of therapies, have actually resulted in incredible improvements in cardiovascular-related mortality in the United States. These classes of drugs have been a huge success and they have been able to substitute where previously we had to rely on behavioral change. There is an important lesson here. Yes, we’d like to modify behavior. And, yes, behavior change has value. But it is also important that we continue to innovate to find ways where biomedicine can fill those gaps.

Q: How do you see California leading the way in terms of healthcare following the Affordable Care Act, with so many uninsured?

A: As in so many areas, California is one of those states that defines the way other states will react to policies. As you know, we face a severe fiscal and economic crisis in the state. It is easy to say one of the reasons for this is healthcare, so we should be working hard to reduce reimbursement in many areas. But it is important to realize that California is also the engine for biotechnology and biomedicine is one of the engines of growth in this state.

California has a reasonably competitive health insurance market. In the private sector, they have been initiating reforms that will drive reimbursement down where it needs to be driven down. And it will drive up where we need to reward value. We should be careful to make sure that we encourage those markets to work as efficiently as possible. And that may mean even raising reimbursement in some areas.

Q: What’s been consuming the majority of your time these days?

A: I have been spending my time trying to think about other ways that we can 1) reimburse high-value therapy and 2) come up with better models to try and understand the short- and long-implications of disease. For example, if you think about a country’s progress generally, and we tend to look at gross national product or gross domestic product, but we don’t take into account the health benefits that countries might get from various interventions. And that is an important part of progress. We need to find ways to promote not only longevity but also better quality of life when people get older.

There’s been a lot of focus on the ACA and its short-term implications. We are the only center that I know of that is actually thinking about how will this affect innovation in the long-term.

Q: What are you most looking forward to hearing about at “California: Uniting Science and Policy to Advance Cancer Care” on Thursday?

A: I’m looking forward to “The State of Cancer Research in the Golden State” and “Improving Access to Advanced Treatment” panels.

I think it is important we promote access to therapy and we do not end up with a world where we have large disparities in access because only the wealthy can get access to these therapies. At the same time, we have to make sure we can reimburse them appropriately.

Really, access to care is going to be a key issue going forward.




CHI-Advancing California biomedical research and innovation

Bookmark and Share